In Session: Sidebar  « Back to Blog Main
July 29, 2009

Cleared murder defendant looks toward future

Posted: 03:32 PM ET

NEW YORK – When the jury declared Tyler Edmonds not guilty in the murder of his brother-in-law last year, the emotion on both sides of the courtroom was palpable. Behind Edmonds sat his mother and rows of friends his own age; tears flowed and the stunned teenager received a barrage of hugs before he walked out of the courtroom a free man.

Tyler Edmonds

Still sitting on the opposite side of the gallery were the mother, brother, and sister-in-law of his alleged victim Joey Fulgham – a 29-year-old father of three, whose life ended when a single bullet pierced his skull as he lay sleeping in his bed. I was struck by the severe look on the faces of all three as they stared straight ahead. I asked Joey’s brother Shannon Fulgham about it when we met for an interview a few weeks later; pain and disbelief, he said.

Edmonds, now 20, is working as a yard and pool keeper, and begins night classes at the local community next month with an EMT/Paramedic major. He has filed a suit against Oktibbeha County and the state for monetary compensation, to help with the $60,000 debt he says he and his mother have amassed since his legal troubles began. The complaint paints a stark picture of the teen’s time behind bars: “Tyler witnessed multiple instances of inmates attempting suicide by slitting their wrists and continuous threats by inmates to jump off the catwalk. Tyler was surrounded by gangs and gang wars at all times while incarcerated, an atmosphere that would be intolerable for any adult, much less a child of his age,” the document reads.

Edmonds has also filed a claim under a new Mississippi law that entitles wrongfully imprisoned individuals to up to $50,000 per year of incarceration; for Edmonds, this could add up to $200,000.

The case had dragged on since Joey’s death in 2003, when his wife Kristi allegedly recruited her 13-year-old half-brother Tyler Edmonds as an accomplice in her husband’s murder. All seem to agree Kristi is a masterful manipulator, but Tyler’s role – and level of responsibility – was left for the jury to determine. He was already convicted of the murder once, at the age of 14, but that verdict was overturned by the State Supreme Court. And here he was again at the defense table, at 19, hearing the words he’d been waiting for; the seal on his walking papers. “It is amazing how that much worry and pain can be taken away by two words,” he told me later. He’s prayed, he said, that the Fulgham family will realize he did not kill Joey – but has come to realize there is nothing he can do about it.

Shannon Fulgham says one of the most difficult things for the family has been watching the rallying of support for Edmonds based largely on his age. Few of the individuals and organizations to step forward know the facts of the case, he says; none have expressed concern for Joey’s essentially orphaned children, who now are in the care of Kristi’s mother.

In an update Edmonds sent me last week, he says it’s comforting to be able to look towards the future without worrying about going back to jail. “It's still hard sometimes, but considering all that I've survived thus far, something tells me I will be quite alright.”

Kristi, now on death row for the murder, has written him and apologized, he says; he has no intention of responding.

-Lena Jakobsson, In Session field producer

Filed under: Trial Updates


Share this on:
Chris K.   July 29th, 2009 5:21 pm ET

I think the mothers testimony is very compelling. I believe her. But the clincher for me is the legality of her testimony. She said that when she was taken to the other area at the sheriffs office, she kept telling them over and over that she did not want them to interrogate her son without her presence. They kept asking her for her permission but at the same time, in the other area where her son was, they already got a false confession.

Now forgive me for saying this but the boy seems to be closer to his mama if you know what i mean. I'm closer to my mom as well and its because my father hardly did anything with me. So I gravitated toward my mother. And I've taken on some of her kind and gentle traits also. That is why I believe that this boy didn't do this. His mother took care of him and had his best interest in mind, yes. But his mother and sister, due to the mothers testimony on how much the daughter was manipulative, probably had some bad times at home. The son seeing, this probably missed his sister a lot and found her life to be adventurous in contrast to his mothers stable life. Therefore, with that said, he would have lied and said anything for his sister. He loved her and like this episode stated, he was his sisters protector....

Deb I   July 29th, 2009 7:43 pm ET

It is so sad to think that maybe the best lesson to be learned here is: don't ever talk to the police without a lawyer present. It seems that police do not want justice, they just want to get someone, anyone, accused of the crime. Very very sad. So glad this young man has his life returned to him.

Mree   July 30th, 2009 8:58 am ET

I'm very happy for this young man.

Jackie Earl   July 30th, 2009 9:43 am ET

Sadly, many Americans have reached the point of no return when it comes to "celebrity" and will do anything, including assasinating their OWN character, just to get on TV. It is truly mind-boggling to me how so many Americans can think so little of themselves, as well as very disheartening.

Jackie
Erie, PA

Daniel   July 30th, 2009 11:28 am ET

It’s a good thing I’m not in the jury the lack of someone who is his step sister not saying anything that could help clear her step brother in my opinion works against the defendant. She has nothing to loose so why try to help him by speaking, and saying it was all her.

Me in Raleigh   July 30th, 2009 11:47 am ET

I am so mad at Tyler's mother, for not keeping up with him and his 1/2 sisters time together. The Police Dept., I have NO due respect for them. I feel they are responsible and should be held accountable, for coercing a 13 yr old "Child", into a confession. Where are the confession papers, from Kristi? Why wasn't Tyler put in a home for teen-agers so he could receive help in standing up to people that feel it is right to manipulate children. All states differ in trying a child. Don't you find it strange that now he is 19? He may still look 13...but he is not. My heart goes out to him. This trial, and the so called adults that manipulated him, have taken Tyler's childhood away from him. I pray that he will gain strength and remember life is about choices. It takes children a while to believe that.....sometimes....they never do, because of Police that are pushy, break laws to get results, and family members that don't incorporate that into their own lifestyles. (Mom needs to get a life...and Dad, for that matter)

Me in Raleigh   July 30th, 2009 11:56 am ET

AH! From what I am reading, Tyler is free. I'm relieved. No One that was ever around that young man thought of him as a "bad person". I hope he has learned, to only believe in yourself. It really bothers me, being a sister "stuck in the middle" of 4 brothers....the times I took my younger brother's out on dates with me to shoot trap and skeet....Should an accident occurred....we would tell a straight story...If people would learn a little honesty and incorporate it in their life and their children's life, Life would be easier for everyone. (I still do not respect the Police that cornered this young man into a confession). I hope they can live with themselves, because I surely would not ever want to live with one of them. That town needs some new officers. I think all police officers require a class in psycology...

Cyndie W.   July 30th, 2009 12:24 pm ET

I think Tyler is a victim of his sister's criminal behavior. He was 13 years old at the time, and of course could have gone to the police. But a 13 year old will want to please their parent/guardian. I believe he felt he wanted to please his sister, and she was not going to take "no" for an answer. Also, if Kristi Folgham was helping Tyler hold the gun, then that is a huge sign that Tyler never wanted to hold the gun and shoot Joey. Tyler may not have liked Joey, but just because someone doesn't like someone else, it doesn't mean they will go out and shoot hat person the next day. Kristi forced him, and she did that by manipulating her little brother. She coaxed him into pulling the trigger and making him feel comfortable shooting Joey by helping Tyler hold the gun.

Thomas   July 30th, 2009 12:48 pm ET

Tyler’s statement that he was the last one out of the house and Joey was still alive because he waved to him is true because this was the first time that they left after eating Subway. This ties into the unscrewed light bulb. Kristi made Joey believe that she was taking Tyler to his father’s after eating and Joey went to bed. Tyler said goodbye and Tyler Kristi and the youngest child left the house with Tyler leaving last locking the door.

In statements Tyler made statements later claiming he was in the car when Joey was shot was true also, as he was outside in the car when Kristi snuck into the house through the door where the light was disabled and shot Joey in the back of the head. Tyler said he heard the pop sound “like a book fell on the floor,” Tyler was needed at the time to watch the youngest child in the car while this took place. Afterwards Kristi brought Tyler and the youngest child into the house for the night and Tyler at first was sleeping on the floor next to Kristi who was on the computer most likely saving files (pictures) off the hard drive.

The morning came and Joey’s alarm clock went off awakening Kristi and Tyler. Tyler woke up and found Kristi in Joey room most likely turning off the alarm. The scenario that Tyler told in his video taped confession is what happened next and it was a recreation of the crime that Kristi in her warped mind did to show Tyler how she did it. She wrapped her arms around Tyler as he said with the gun in hand and pulled the trigger. This was upsetting to Tyler who threw the gun down and left the room. They then gathered up items to make it look like a robbery and left the house to pick up the other children and go to the coast for the weekend.

Klaatu   July 30th, 2009 1:21 pm ET

I hope he gets a ton of money...not that it will make up for the hell he has been through at the hands of the jailers and a "justice" system that allows a child to be put in jail solely on the word of a manipulative, lying person.

Too bad the cops, detectives and guards dont have to pay the legal fees and the compensation themselves...I bet they'd change their behavior in a hurry...

Poor kid

Doug McConnell   July 30th, 2009 1:23 pm ET

Having worked with children and youth for over 40 years I find it inexcusable to interrogate any child below the age of 14 or even 16 without at least a parent present. Youth this young do not know the ramifications of their statements, do not know that they may need legal counsel, do not fully know right from wrong and can be very easily manipulated by adults particularly those in positions of authority. Legal rights should protect these individuals by mandating that they have independent legal representation present during any and all questioning. It is not good enough to have parents or legal guardians present as all too often they are involved in the crimes for which the youth are being questioned.

Doug McConnell, MS

Robin Butler   July 30th, 2009 1:56 pm ET

I think our justice system needs a MAJOR over hauling. This is not the first case that children have been abused by the justice system. Has anyone filed charges against the authorities for child abuse? If I did this to a child I would go to jail. So how can the police and prosecutors get away with abuse? This is clearly abuse. This kind of stuff makes me so mad. I want to go back to school and become a lawyer just to throw this abusers in jail. See how they like sharing a 6 X 6 cell with Big Bubba.

creeto   July 30th, 2009 2:33 pm ET

why is this person being tried twice for the same crime? wasn't his conviction overturned by the supreme court? what about double jeopardy? not fully understanding... if his step-sister has been convicted of the crime he is being charged with for a second time...

Sonya   July 30th, 2009 2:40 pm ET

I think most of u see a little white boy & say he was just not telling the truth @ first but I look & see a person that told the truth @ first & then talked 2 his mother & lawyers & then changed his mind I do think he helped his sister & the police was right most kids won't say anything with the parents there. The police did not make him say anything & I have a 13 year old & u can't make them admit 2 anything they did not do not even 2 help a sister or brother.

Patricia   July 30th, 2009 2:51 pm ET

I am very happy that he was not found guilty. However the real trial is now and that is forgiveness. I read that she said that she was sorry and that he will not respond. Forgiveness is the ending statment to this trial.

Frankie M Bolton   July 30th, 2009 5:37 pm ET

I pray for Tyler but, more for our justice system. Convict some one, any one, just get it closed. I pray that Tyler's life doesn't suffer because of this experience. God bless.

Cyndie W.   July 30th, 2009 5:49 pm ET

I'm so glad Tyler was found not guilty. He does not deserve to be put in jail. He can finally look towards the future. Unfortunately, his future will be very difficult, but he will have to persevere. But I am so happy he is able to walk free.

Cyndie W.   July 30th, 2009 5:56 pm ET

(In response to Sonya) 1. Race has nothing to do with the situation 2. You are only speaking from experience with your 13 year old. Not every 13 year old is the same. I'm not saying that you're experience with your 13 year old is not valid, because it is, but your 13 year old is going to be different from your neighbor's 13 year old.

Legally, he should not have been interrogated without a lawyer or guardian. It was wrong for the police to interrogate him without one. He was at a critical age that he does not 100% understand what he was saying and didn't realize what he was saying could have committed him to prison.

alan sweeney   July 30th, 2009 8:00 pm ET

Ron, I think I may have the answer to your question. Why would tyler take"half" the blame? He can't bring himself to take the whole blame, but in his childish view, he thinks maybe he can take "half" the blame. By mitigating the blame that his sister has to take, he thinks he can "help" her. Possibility?

Maria   July 31st, 2009 9:04 am ET

It's wrong to treat a 13-year-old like an adult. That's why people are for Tyler Edmonds. One thing I learned from this trial: Tru-TV should keep Ron Kuby and showcase his knowledge and broadcasting talent. Go Ron!

Angelia D.   July 31st, 2009 9:50 am ET

The police dept. needs to be trained in interrogating under aged children the proper way in a serious crime as this. I do believe that Tyler Edmonds is innocent. A 13 year old scared child who finds himself in a situation of murder, and there is a older person telling him to say all of these things to the police or he won't see his family again is very tramatic. If this was a case where he was guilty, he still could have possibly been found "not guilty", because of the way the police handle the situation. There wasn't a parent or a lawyer present when he was being questioned, and the child could of said that he was confused and didn't understand what the police was asking.

Jessie   July 31st, 2009 11:57 am ET

First of all, I do not beieve this child took part in the death of Joey Fulgham. I have no respect for the Mississippi authorities. They, along with Kristi, manipulated this kid. He is innocent.

Cal   July 31st, 2009 12:03 pm ET

I am 21 years of age From Fay, NC just an ordinary everday citizen. I believe that tyler is innocent. I believe his sister in-law munipulated her lil brother in law. Told him exactly what to say to police on the way to the coast. I believe that tyler was young and nieve and believed he was protecting his sister. This is a young HUMAN BEING and i feel that he deserves LIFE(free that is). Plaese do not send an innocent child to prison...

Randy Branch   July 31st, 2009 12:04 pm ET

I believe that the defendant shouldn't be held accountable for the simple reason that, he was 13 years old and was manipulated, and tossed away like broken toy by his twisted Half-Sister who used her influence to make him participate in her sceme.

brittany!   July 31st, 2009 12:06 pm ET

I still don't know what to think.
I remember this case in 2003 but
its been so confusing.....
I just want who ever did it to be prosecuted.
Cause an innocent man died.

brittany!   July 31st, 2009 12:19 pm ET

his sister did the crime he didnt.
he shouldnt suffer anymore, the police
have caused enough grief to him....
but he should forgive her, so he can be freee
from all stress

richard.stephens   July 31st, 2009 12:21 pm ET

in the defense of tyler, would it be possible that tyler was mentally and maybe physically 2-3 years behind, like they say compared to females in general. that would make him 10-11 years old mentally

Liz   July 31st, 2009 12:40 pm ET

Kristi isn't going to take full responsibility because she is still going to have her appeals to fight the death sentence. She has already proven she cares only about herself. If she helps her brother now she will have no chance of escaping the death sentence.

Jessie   July 31st, 2009 12:42 pm ET

The authorites already have the twisted sister on death row. How many more lives have to be lost because of this sick individual (meaning Kristi Fulgham)?

Joe   July 31st, 2009 1:13 pm ET

I'm happy to see that he is free but unfortunately he'll live in a world where some people will still see him a killer no matter what. To me, the sad part of our society is that we are guilty until proven innocent, and even in the case that your are proven innocent nothing will ever be enough for some people.

Greg   July 31st, 2009 1:14 pm ET

I feel that the reason for Tyler's original confession was due to manipulation. He was most likely told that since he is a child he would get a slap on the hand as opposed to her getting a very serious charge.

LL   July 31st, 2009 1:14 pm ET

I feel a child that age and from the testimony, a good boy at the time.
Well he was forced into being apart of this,I am glad he got off this time around,,,
I just hope being incarcerated will not ruin his life.
And that being cooped up has not made him sour.

gary ca.   July 31st, 2009 1:53 pm ET

THIS KID HAS SERVED ENOUGH TIME FOR HIS PART IN THIS CRIME.I SAY SEND HIM HOME.HE HAS ALREADY LOST HIS CHILDHOOD,THANKS TO HIS HALF SISTER.LETS SHOW A LITTLE MERSY

solanna   July 31st, 2009 2:19 pm ET

i do not belive tyler is responsable for this murder i belive his older sister kristy acted alone and should be prosocuted alone

Gretchen   July 31st, 2009 2:36 pm ET

I find it odd that there were video tapes made of Tyler 's questioning and statements but missing the time with the mother out of the room.

There was video of Tyler alone with his mother, yet even more unusual that there was no video of Tyler conversing with HIS SISTER .....
Did they think it necessary to turn off the camera or lose the tapes?

T-Bird   July 31st, 2009 2:41 pm ET

I'm glad Tyler was found innocent. However, I must say that if that prosecutor didn't totally suck, the verdict would have been different.

Carter   July 31st, 2009 2:54 pm ET

I'm from Columbus Mississippi, and if we had someone to look into alot of the cases that goes on Columbus Mississippi alot of them would be over turned. They dont look into the cases like a suppose too. The judges, da's and the police officers are all working with eachother. One of the judges take it personal that his child died of drug use. Justice is not justice down here. We have no voice. If we had someone to look into the system down here we would have more cases on your show. We need the media help in Columbus Mississippi and maybe alot will change. Thanks

chris   July 31st, 2009 3:12 pm ET

I am very happy that the boy was freed. There is no way a child should of
1. Been tried as an adult
2. The Police were not charged criminal for thier illegal acts that lead to this boy to hell and back.
What should happen:
1. A very large financial award for the boy, whereas the blanket that the
police have PROTECTING THEM FROM BEING ACCOUNTABLE for their actions in a civil suit be lifted and they be held personally financial responsible for the debt they owe this boy,
2. The young man have counseling for life,
3. The young man be given school and trainning
This is the least they owe the young man, Most assured the police should be paying this boy, with thier bank accounts and pensions,
Maybe they would not be quick to break the law, and not take someones freedom without any after thought. They are the lowest of the low in my opinion. FIRE THEM ALL

Liz   July 31st, 2009 4:31 pm ET

To the person who was saying they need more media attention in their state concerning officers, da's and judges? Trust me, this corruption with law enforcement is happening everywhere. It's totally out of control.

Elisabeth   July 31st, 2009 6:05 pm ET

Thank you JESUS,

I believe he will become a productive member in society and make a way for himself. Go forth Edmond and live your life without stress and worry. Once again all praises to you CHRIST JESUS OUR LORD. Thank you Tru Tv for viewing this trial. Trials such as these give our young people hope that our Justice system is still strong and unbias.

WG   July 31st, 2009 6:21 pm ET

I'm so happy he was found not guilty. Ifeel the DA's, Jailers, Sheriff actions all should be looked into. They knew he was not guilty.

LeAnn   July 31st, 2009 6:36 pm ET

I am a 43 yr. old woman who used to be one of those people who believed that innocent persons should talk to the police if they have nothing to hide. NOT ANY MORE!!!
I have been watching in session for a few months and I tell ya what, weather I have anything to hide or not I am NOT talking without a lawyer. It seems that the police does try to get anyone they can to just close their case. This (in my humble opinion) is wrong!!

martin   July 31st, 2009 7:57 pm ET

It would seem the police have their own set rules that differ from the public....

John B   August 3rd, 2009 10:45 am ET

I am very happy and pleased to see that the justice system works for defendts who are innocent, Tyler Congarats and enjoy your FREEDOM.
Your defense team did a wonderful job!!!

Linda   August 3rd, 2009 12:05 pm ET

After watching Tyler's trial, almost every day, I realised nothing much has changed in Mississippi. This state has always been the last and certainly not better for anything happening in this state. If this state had anyone with guts in higher places cases like this would hold ALL police officers responsible for their actions. It is quite clear these "oh so capable and professional" police officers are nothing but thugs themselves. Why would they only have a "confession" on tape and his mother talking with him on tape and nothing what ever on tape about the polices' questioning or in this case, apparently, bullyinig this thirteen year old child. The last time I looked this is still the United States and the legal age is still EIGHTEEN years old. It might just be time for the federal government in Washington to take a long
and lengthy look at the so called legal system in Mississippi. At lease
require all interrogations to be filmed and if not totally filmed throw out what is given as HONEST police work. The system should work for all the people in any state and not for police officers and their cronies.

This case makes me sick. A thirteen year old child questioned by himself when his mother was on the premises just shows how desperate the police department was to CLOSE their case and in any way they saw fit. Maybe, now is the time for Mississippi to clean house and take a long look at the abuse handed out by what should be honest and dependable police officers.

I only wish Mississippi would hold these corupt officers responsible both legally and financially for their actions. This defendant has been through a living hell for something he could not have planned and carried out. However, Tyler's sister is exactly where she belongs and I hope she never gets relief and excapes the death penalty. This sister is pure evil and thank God the jury saw her for what she is, a murderer. Did anyone ever try to see how difficult it would be for two people to put their fingers into the small opening around the trigger of a long barreled gun? This child would have to be holding his arms way over his head and aiming the gun at the same time, doesn't make sense to anyone surely?

I wish nothing but the very best for this young man and hope the rest of his life will be filled with love, laughter and joy. Best of luck Tyler.

LJM   August 3rd, 2009 7:07 pm ET

I wish Tyler all the best with his freedom, and I pray that he get a large sum from the people that took his childhood away from him. Its a shame that the officers didn't have to pay this out of there own, takening responsiblity for what they did in taken Tyler's childhood. And Tyler use the money to make the best of life for yourself, God bless you now and always

judi   August 4th, 2009 10:14 am ET

Finally, justice is served. Why the confession was even admissable is questionable. His rights were violated! The DA should have just dropped the charges before wasting the taxpayers money on a second trial. I don't know how the first jury sleeps at night. Kudos to the second jury.......and good luck to Tyler!

leigh painter   August 4th, 2009 9:14 pm ET

Tyler if you read this I'm very happy for you...becareful of the decisions you make and I pray the Lord will bless you with his word, there is none like it....God bless you Tyler....Leigh

Mary   August 5th, 2009 3:55 pm ET

I think the best lesson learned here is that if anyone thinks someone is in danger, Warn Them! and tell an authority figure, who is not related by family or emplyment, such as a police detective. If this young man had done this, this man might be alive today.

Kathy   August 7th, 2009 6:54 am ET

I hope that Tyler uses any reimbursements that he receives just for himself. He needs to use it for his education and moving expenses to get far away from his hometown in Mississippi and the crooked law enforcement. Maybe a trustee could be assigned so that his (QUARTER) sister and his mother couldn't find a false reason to get their hands on it. His sister will only be needing it for a short time. Let someone else pay for her defense. He's already paid with 6 years of his youth. His mother should have kept track a little better of where he was. Being a single parent, she was trying and always believed in his innocence. It was hard on her to go against her daughter. Thank God she did do that right. She kept after the cops on their interviewing her son without her being the room. Give him a move, free education anywhere of his choice, and compensation, and then Justice will be served!

carol harper   August 9th, 2009 8:26 am ET

im so happy to hear that he was found not guilty.i also had at one time a 13 year old who was warped by the police dept and corrupted and framed.he is now 18 and still incarcerated for the crime he was accused of.he got arrested on his 13th birthday and has been there ever since just because we dont have the money to fight the system.they have ruined his life.as for the victims family i really hope they find closer that someone the real killer is going to be put to death which wont bring there loved one back but someone is paying the price.i hope that joeys family can see that this 13 year old at the time was a victim also and come to see that he didnt do this and forgive him

sondra   August 19th, 2009 2:22 pm ET

i've followed this case but missed the last few days. Therefore, missed the verdict. I am glad to hear he was found not guilty as I've fealt he was mistakenly convicted. I also think his sister is a. . .well, i remain nice.

I salute the jury – Good Job

Sondra

Leave Your Comment


 

Comments are moderated by CNN, in accordance with the CNN Comment Policy, and may not appear on this blog until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting. Also, due to the volume of comments we receive, not all comments will be posted.


subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

Sidebar takes you behind the scenes of the day's legal headlines with breaking news and in-depth analysis from In Session's anchors and correspondents.

Contact us
  • Questions or comments? E-mail
In Session Team
Jean Casarez
Correspondent
Jean Casarez
Beth Karas
Correspondent
Beth Karas
Mike Brooks
Law Enforcement Analyst
Mike Brooks
Midwin Charles
Legal Contributor
Midwin Charles
Sunny Hostin
Legal Contributor
Sunny Hostin
Powered by WordPress.com VIP